Prompt #113

Variables

proposal, context

Tags

critical-thinking,review,adversarial,reasoning

Source

research-2026-05-01

Use count

0

Created

2026-05-01T18:11:52.162090+00:00

Updated

2026-05-01T18:11:52.162090+00:00

Content

Steelman and then attack the following proposal.

Proposal: {{proposal}}
Context: {{context}}

## Steel-Manning
Make the strongest possible case FOR this proposal (3-5 compelling arguments).

## Devil's Advocate Attack
Now argue AGAINST it with equal rigor:
- Technical risks
- Hidden assumptions that could fail
- Second-order effects
- Better alternatives

## Balanced Verdict
Rate the proposal: Strong/Moderate/Weak
Key conditions under which it succeeds vs. fails.
Recommended modifications to make it stronger.